We all know by now one size does not fit all, no matter what the label states. We should also realize the suggested age for a toy or book is a suggestion, and not all children are alike. Neither are adults.
I heard from a relative last week who gave her almost-90-year-old father my novel Not on Fifth Street because he was bored due to pandemic restrictions. He loved the book! She gave him Like a River, and he loved that one too. Next, he read Empty Places, and she wanted other suggestions for books to give him. He is not my first “elderly” reader.
Suggested for ages 8-12? No thanks.
Would he be dismayed if he saw the catalog that lists two of those books for ages 8 to 12? I was and continue to be dismayed by that label, but publishers have rules. I have enjoyed reading books for young readers my entire life. A good story is a good story. Period.
My books are published for young readers because of the ages of the protagonists, but I am well aware that many of my readers are adults. I find that exciting. Both adult and juvenile book clubs read my books. A man who claims to be my “oldest fan” is in his 90’s. Readers shouldn’t be pigeon-holed by age labels.
Ignore the label and find the right story for you
Unfortunately, schools also have rules about such things. Readers miss out because 7thand 8th-grade teachers and librarians are “not allowed” to purchase Empty Places or Not on Fifth Street for their classrooms. Thirteen-year-olds aren’t supposed to read books when the cut-off age is listed as 12. I think the 13-year-old should make the decision. If the reader will enjoy the book, why is it a problem? Any interest in reading should be encouraged. I defy anyone to argue the language and subject matter are not challenging enough.
My books deal with historical events, including disasters. Reading about a flood or a mine cave-in (or learning a bit of history) shouldn’t be limited to twelve and under, should it?
On the other hand, the mother of an 8-year-old told me she wouldn’t buy Empty Places for her child because she believed the subject matter (that mine cave-in, as well as an alcoholic father) is “too mature” for him. She has the right to make that decision. She knows her child. The people who decide the book is for age 8 do not. Not all 8-year-olds are alike, and many 8-year-olds can handle those situations. So can teens and adults.
I’d love to be able to remove age recommendations for my books, or at least include the words “recommended for” or “suggested for.” Better yet, how about “8 and Up?” That label would more accurately define my readers. People are different, in interests and abilities. All are welcome in my books!
And reading is good, no matter how old you are.